Why your dog doesn't come when you call
It isn't the dog that's broken. What's broken is the word you use, more precisely what follows it, and that can be fixed in three stages, with a pass threshold you check yourself.
It's seven in the evening, you're in the park and you call him for the third time. He looks at you. He really does look. And he goes back to what he was doing.
And when he finally comes, after a minute and a half, you do one of two things: either you tell him off, or you put the lead on and you head home.
Let me tell you what your dog learned from this scene. Not what you feel he learned. What he actually learned.
The problem isn't the word. It's what comes after it
Think of a person who is called by name only when bad news is coming. At work, at home, anywhere. The first time they answer straight away. The fifth time they still answer, but after two seconds and with their head down.
The name hasn't changed. What the name announces has changed.
Your dog makes exactly the same calculation, and he makes it much faster than you. If every time you call him what follows is the lead, going home, a bath or a telling-off, then your call is no longer an invitation. It's an announcement. And nobody, on four legs or two, runs happily towards a bad announcement.
To be honest to the end: I'm giving you this part as an explanation, not as a measurement. I haven't found a study that has counted exactly how a recall word wears out through repetition. It's what we see in the field, and it's what you see too if you look at your own walk yesterday. But the two ends of the chain have been measured, and there the figures exist.
The figure that interests me most: what happens when he comes
A 2020 study took 63 dogs and split them into three groups. One trained with an electric collar. One trained by the same trainers, but without it. And one trained by people specialised in reward.
On recall, the third group responded to the first call in 82.5% of cases. The other two: 71% and 72.4%.
Look closely at those figures, because they're more interesting than they seem. The group without the electric collar, but with the same trainers, came out practically the same as the group with the collar. The difference doesn't come from the device. It comes from the way the person at the other end of the lead works. Anyone who tells you "the device is to blame" is simplifying. And anyone who tells you "it hurts, so he comes faster" is wrong on the figures, not on principles.
Eleven percentage points. It isn't a chasm. But it's the difference between a dog that comes the first time and one you have to call once more. Every day. Twice a day.
And now the part that changes everything: that guilty look isn't what you think
You know the expression. The dog comes, late, and makes that face: head down, ears flat, eyes to one side. And you go home reassured that "he understood".
In 2009, a researcher filmed 14 dogs in a series of simple tests. She varied two things: whether the animal had actually broken the ban and whether the owner knew what had happened while they were out of the room.
The result: there was no difference between the dogs that had misbehaved and those that hadn't. The "guilty" look didn't appear according to the deed.
It appeared according to something else. It appeared when the owner scolded. And, this is the part that hurts, the effect was even stronger in the dogs that had been obedient.
Read that sentence again. The dog that hadn't done anything wrong, but was scolded, looked even guiltier than the one that had.
What this means for you, on a Tuesday evening, in the park: the dog that comes late and gets told off doesn't learn "I was wrong to be late". He can't. The moment he ignored you ended a minute and a half ago. What he learns is what's happening now, and right now he's next to you and you're angry.
He learns that arriving next to you is unpleasant. And that face that reassured you is just his response to your state, not a confession.
What else breaks, beyond the recall
A study of 53 human-dog pairs measured the link between the methods used at home and the dog's behaviour. Dogs whose owners used more punishment approached a stranger less. Those that received physical punishment were less playful. And those trained with reward did better at a completely new learning task.
It's a study of association, not of cause, and I'm telling you this so as not to sell you more than is written there. But the direction is clear, and there's an irony in it: badly applied punishment doesn't only break the recall. It breaks exactly the tool you'd want to use to fix the recall.
Why it breaks at around six months exactly
A small puppy follows you everywhere, with or without a lead. Like a five-year-old child who holds your hand without you asking. And people get used to that: they let him off, he comes on his own, everyone is happy.
At around six months, the puppy starts to be "problematic". Nothing has broken in him. He has grown up. Try holding a twelve-year-old's hand.
And that's when the classic scene happens: "come, come, come on, come on, come on", ten times, with the voice getting higher and higher, and the dog doesn't come. Then come the nerves, running after him, catching him, putting the lead on, marching him home. The word you were shouting has become, for him, the signal that something bad is coming.
That's exactly where our programme begins. Not with the dog. With the word.
How we work, so you're not left only with what not to do
The first correction is one of vocabulary: with us, the recall isn't "come". It's "HAI" (Romanian for "come on").
And HAI isn't taught all at once, in the park, at thirty metres. It's taught in three stages, like at school. You can't ask the dog to sit a university exam if he hasn't done first grade. Each stage has a clear threshold, and you don't move on until you've reached it.
What follows is the programme I apply myself, step by step. I filmed it from start to finish, in the field, with a real dog, so you can see exactly what you're reading here: https://youtu.be/uWpktVHBy7k
The reward, before anything else. Choose a prize your dog never gets any other way. With us it's grilled meat: pieces of chicken done over charcoal, no salt, no seasoning, prepared in advance and kept in the freezer. It doesn't matter what you choose, the rule matters: that prize is given only for HAI. Never for anything else. We want this sound to be written in his brain with a single meaning: when I hear HAI, the big prize comes.
Stage 1, in the house or in the yard. The dog has smelled the food and comes all over you. You push him gently away with your hand and say SPACE. It doesn't need to be a big distance. He just needs to understand that you don't want him glued to you. Then, when he's a step or two away from you, you say HAI. And for every small step he takes towards you, you praise him and reward him. One step. That's all we want. Then again: SPACE, HAI, one step, prize.
It may seem pointless to you. It may seem to make no sense. But this is what it means to start from the very lowest level with your dog. You move him away a little, you call him, you reward him. You move him away a little, you call him, you reward him.
Two things to note. One: when you call him, you call him loudly. You want it to be very clear what you're asking of him. Two: you start praising him from the moment he sets off towards you, not when he has arrived. Setting off is what you want to reinforce.
Here you need patience. Once he has understood that the meat is with you, he'll stay glued to you and won't go anywhere. Don't chase him away. Wait for something else to draw him, a smell, a corner of the yard, and only then call him again. And once more. And once more.
The stage 1 threshold: ten correct recalls in a row. Off the lead, in the yard or in the house, you say HAI once and he comes the first time. Ten in a row. Not nine out of ten, not "he usually comes". Ten consecutive. Only then are you allowed to move on.
Stage 2, in a field or in the park, when it's quiet. This is where the long line comes in: a thin cord of about twenty metres, attached to the flat collar, instead of the lead. It lets him explore, move away, sniff out tracks, but safely. Why safely? Because he's a puppy and you have no guarantee that he can control his impulses at this age. If he picks up a hare's trail and "doesn't hear you", the long line is what lets you bring him back without running after him.
Choose the place carefully. No roads, no cars, no other dogs, no people. It's the learning stage, not the consolidation stage. The dog is in nursery school: you want the calmest possible environment, so that he can understand what you're asking of him.
And you'll see something beautiful: in a new place he doesn't know, the dog doesn't go very far from you. He stops, he looks back. Not because you called him. Because he trusts you, and an unknown place is only safe with the person you trust next to you. It's called secure attachment, and it works the same way in your dog and in your child: a being needs someone trustworthy nearby in order to explore calmly.
You work the same way: you let him move away ten, fifteen metres, you say HAI once, loudly, and when he sets off towards you the praise begins, and when he arrives the prize comes. The stage 2 threshold: ten correct recalls in a row, from a distance, the first time.
Stage 3, the dog completely free, in the field. Only now do you take everything off: the long line and the collar it was attached to. Nothing on him. It isn't a reward for you, it's his final exam: the same field, the same tracks of hare and deer, but this time you no longer have any cord to pull. You only have the word and what you built in the first two stages.
You work exactly the same way, with the same patience: you let him explore, move away, find something interesting, and only then do you say HAI. Once, loudly. Praise from the instant he sets off, the prize when he arrives, and you send him back to exploring. If he got here with the stages done, you'll see something that surprises you: he comes back on his own, every now and then, to see where you are. You didn't call him. He doesn't want to go too far from his person in a place he doesn't control.
The rule for the moment you're afraid of, which belongs to stage 3. The dog is free, he sees a hare or a deer and bolts. What do you do? You don't run after him. Under no circumstances. You turn your back and walk off decisively in the opposite direction, shouting HAI at the top of your lungs.
I know it's hard. I know it's the opposite of what you feel like doing. I know the fear in that moment is huge. But here's why: you and your dog are a pack. If you run after him, you confirm to him that the pack is moving in that direction, that the pack is chasing the hare. If you walk off in the opposite direction, the dog stops and thinks: "Wait a moment. I'm running that way, and my person is walking off decisively the other way. Maybe I'm wrong." And he comes. I don't run after the dog so as not to confirm to him that that's where the pack is going. I show him that the pack is leaving on the right path.
One thing about you, not about him. The moment you say HAI and the dog sets off towards you, make a fool of yourself. Joy, energy, voice, applause. I want you to match the speed at which he approaches you with the enthusiasm you show him. To tell him that you're just as delighted as he is that he heard that sound.
The pair almost everyone misses: FREE
If you give the dog "free", the whole lead, sniffing, exploring, toilet, then freedom is something you have given. And what you have given you can also take back.
If, however, the dog took his freedom by himself, from the front door, you have nothing left to take back. You have nothing to call him back from, because you weren't the one who let him go.
That's why the programme begins with SPACE. Who decides when the dog comes close and who decides when he leaves: that's the whole recall, in two words.
And so there's no doubt at all: at KNES there is correction
We're not the school where the dog does whatever it wants and everyone smiles. There is a clear "no", there are limits, there are consequences, and there is a ladder we climb one rung at a time: breath, sound, movement, contact. Never impact. And we stop the instant the dog gives way.
Only that ladder applies at the moment the unwanted behaviour happens. Not a minute and a half later.
The dog that has just arrived next to you isn't doing anything wrong in that second. He's doing exactly what you asked, late. Telling him off when he comes back isn't a rung on the ladder. It's a mistake of timing. And I'm not telling you this to be soft on the dog, I'm telling you because it's the mistake that cuts away the very result you want.
The programme, in short, so you can start it tomorrow
Choose the prize and reserve it. Grilled meat, or whatever you choose, but only for HAI. Never for anything else.
Stage 1, at home. SPACE, HAI, one step towards you, prize. A few times a day, two minutes. Praise from the instant he sets off. The threshold: ten consecutive first-time recalls, off the lead, in the house or the yard.
Stage 2, in the field or in an empty park, with the long line. Twenty metres of safe freedom. The same rule, the same praise, the same prize. The threshold: ten in a row from a distance.
Stage 3, in the field, completely free. Collar and long line off, nothing on him. The same call, the same prize, with real temptations around. And the golden rule of the stage: never run after him. You walk off in the opposite direction, you shout HAI, the pack moves. And never tell off a dog that has come, however late, however angry you are.
Repeat. The programme isn't installed once and for all. With a dog between six months and two years old, you go back over it roughly every month. With an adult, three or four times a year. In the field, with real temptations, with things that distract him, not in the kitchen.
If you want to see what each stage looks like in reality, not just on paper, the full tutorial is on the KNES YouTube channel, 25 minutes, with everything you've read above shown on a dog: https://youtu.be/uWpktVHBy7k
One thing from me, so we're honest to the end
I'm not promising you that after two weeks he'll come from any situation. A dog running after a cat across the road is another subject and another discussion.
But I promise you something else, and you can check it in your own yard: if you do the stages in order and don't skip the threshold of ten, and if you never again tell him off when he reaches you, you'll see the difference in the speed at which he sets off towards you when he hears HAI. Not in obedience. In speed.
That's the figure you can measure yourself. And that tells you everything.
It's unfair to the dog to take his lead off and expect him to know what HAI means, without having done our own homework first. When we do it, the association stays positive for the rest of his life: after HAI there is always the prize, the smile and his person's pride. Not the lead and the road home.
If you want to understand why everything you've read here works, the first step is KNESsence, the free material in which I've put the essence of the system we work by at KNES. Create an account on knes.ro, you'll get a six-digit code by email and go straight to it.
With care for your dog,
Petre ROMAN
This material is for educational purposes and does not replace an assessment by a behaviour specialist. If you suspect fear, panic or a very strong hunting instinct behind your dog running off, don't let him off the lead on the basis of this text: ask for an individual, in-person assessment.
Comments